Nathaniel Wood vs Losene Keita
UFC Fight Night 270
Controversy Score: 70/100
Level: High
Close Rounds: 2
The MMA Judge Performance Tracker
Tracking MMA judges, analyzing controversial scorecards, and ranking judge performance using Round Consensus Score and MMA Ledger Score.
Most Controversial Fights
View All Fights →View Fight
Lawrence Lui vs Rangbo Sulang
UFC 325
Controversy Score: 55/100
Level: Moderate
Close Rounds: 1
Farid Basharat vs Jean Matsumoto
UFC Fight Night 266
Controversy Score: 55/100
Level: Moderate
Close Rounds: 1
Most Controversial Rounds
View All Fights →Movsar Evloev vs Lerone Murphy
UFC Fight Night 270 • Round 1
Winner: Movsar Evloev
Vote: 2-1
Round Score: 90/100
Type: Close
✅ Majority: Ben Cartlidge, Derek Cleary
❌ Outlier: Clemens Werner
Justin Gaethje vs Paddy Pimblett
UFC 324 • Round 5
Winner: Justin Gaethje
Vote: 2-1
Round Score: 80/100
Type: Close
✅ Majority: Derek Cleary, Sal D'Amato
❌ Outlier: Mike Bell
Alexander Volkanovski vs Diego Lopes
UFC 325 • Round 2
Winner: Alexander Volkanovski
Vote: 2-1
Round Score: 80/100
Type: Close
✅ Majority: Sal D'Amato, Clemens Werner
❌ Outlier: Ben Cartlidge
Most Controversial Judges
View All Judges →Tony Weeks
Outlier Rate: 33.3%
Controversial Calls: 0
Consensus Score: 66.7%
Rounds Judged: 3
Ron McCarthy
Outlier Rate: 16.7%
Controversial Calls: 0
Consensus Score: 77.8%
Rounds Judged: 18
Marlon Perry
Outlier Rate: 16.7%
Controversial Calls: 0
Consensus Score: 83.3%
Rounds Judged: 6
Most Accurate Judges
View All Judges →Antonio Carrillo
Consensus Score: 100.0%
MMA Ledger Score: 100.0%
Outlier Rate: 0.0%
Rounds Judged: 3
Antonio Guerrero
Consensus Score: 100.0%
MMA Ledger Score: 100.0%
Outlier Rate: 0.0%
Rounds Judged: 3
Anders Ohlsson
Consensus Score: 100.0%
MMA Ledger Score: 100.0%
Outlier Rate: 0.0%
Rounds Judged: 12
Latest Articles
Was This a Robbery? Simon vs Yanez
March 2026
Breaking down the controversial decision.
Read ArticleWeekly Judge Rankings
View Full Rankings →- #1Antonio Carrillo
1 fights • 3 rounds
Consensus: 100.0%Ledger: 100.0% - #2Antonio Guerrero
1 fights • 3 rounds
Consensus: 100.0%Ledger: 100.0% - #3Anders Ohlsson
4 fights • 12 rounds
Consensus: 100.0%Ledger: 100.0% - #4Charlie Keech
2 fights • 6 rounds
Consensus: 100.0%Ledger: 100.0% - #5Adalaide Byrd
2 fights • 6 rounds
Consensus: 100.0%Ledger: 100.0%
About MMA Ledger
MMA Ledger tracks judging performance across MMA events and re-scores controversial fights using modern scoring criteria. Judges are evaluated using both Round Consensus Score and MMA Ledger Score to provide a more complete picture of performance, consistency, and outlier tendencies.